Who would you pick out of these two?

So lets say you were crushing on this guy/girl for AGES, but they just never noticed you. then you met this other guygirl at school, who everyone says wasnt that attractive, and you think so too. But their personality is amazing and you get along well. But then however your crush takes an interest to you, (s)he's smokin hot (lol) but hasnt got the personality like the other guy/girl. then the dilemma happens, they both ask you out, and you dont know who to say yes to. So for a bit of fun, who would you choose? lol thanks for answering !